The bad guy FM master Wang Shuo: Criticism is actually two words, one is called annotation, one is called the comment
I have read a sentence that the French philosopher Foucault
said. He said that literary criticism is the expression of his own literary
works on other people's works. I think he makes a lot of sense, so I think that
literary criticism is the first to have literary criticism, and the second is
to listen to various voices without prejudice.
There is no difference between me and the sense of
listening, but some people are said to be music critics, so some people
mistakenly believe that the music critics write a post-sounding feeling called
"music commentary", which is not called The music critics wrote,
"After listening." There is no difference, in essence, it is a problem
of salutation. For the general public, I don't think it's necessary to watch
music reviews.
Sometimes we confuse a concept, that is, criticism.
Criticism is two words, one is an annotation and the other is a comment.
Comment, comment, there are two preconditions, one is to listen more, read
more, or not able to make notes.
I don't think I am a music critic. I just happen to be a bad
guy FM. Whenever there are new songs by musicians, I will ask them to talk
about the story behind the new song creation. I am also willing to listen to
every music. The motives and ideas of people when creating songs, even the
environment at the time of creation.
So I am especially fortunate that I have been doing bad guys
for so many years and interviewed some bands. I also probably know why some
songs are written, how come... and so on, and I can still comment on some
songs. But commenting on this piece I think I am not professional enough now.
The final product on the spot and the show is still
different. There is a “sweat smell” on the scene. Only the impact that can be
brought by the scene, the record is the art of pursuing perfection, and the
scene is not a perfect art. When I look at the scene, I prefer to see those
things that are not shown on the record.
Deng Ke: Music reviews are really able to influence creation.
We appreciate the need for the cost of music. It may be very
practical. The money I have at hand is only enough to buy a record. Who buys
it? I definitely want to refer to other people's opinions. Although listening
to music is relatively free now, time is limited, so if someone wants to know more,
they may need to go through variety shows or read music reviews.
When you are really moved by a piece of music, you will want
to dig into the information in it. It may be gossip, maybe the music itself.
These content require music reviews as explanations and guides, interpret
places you may not understand, guide you to look at the work from multiple
angles, or use a song or an album, you are interested in someone, You can also
systematically understand him through music review articles.
Music has objective criteria, but it is also subjective. It
is a dialectical relationship, and we must understand this dialectical
relationship. In the process of the whole art, art appreciation and commentary
are very important, and they complete the art acceptance together. Acceptance
is not an instant, it is a continuous process. The first time you listened to
this song, I listened to you ten times, or after listening to it for a long
time, or after many years, I feel different when I listen.
Music reviews can really have an impact on creation.
Something that arises during the creative process of the creator, or a limited
comment, can affect the creator itself. Pop music is fully commercial music.
Therefore, popular music relies on mass media in particular. Many definitions
and combings of music styles are actually done by the media.
Some people may think that art should not be evaluated, but
this view can't stand the scrutiny. The simplest counter-evidence is, if art
can't be evaluated, how can the music school enroll students, and how does the
music school give scholarships?
When I write a music review, I must first sing a song,
including harmony, structure, etc., then listen to the instructor on the
ingenuity, then check the information to see who the songwriter is, the
producer is Who is there any special musician, this work belongs to the
singer's work, where is it in his entire work system, what awards has he won
and is there any value on the public level?
Music has a strong cultural identity.
Music is sometimes just a representation. You have to put
the songs on larger and larger historical data to determine the impact of the
music. These are the places to be considered for writing music reviews.
Many people have problems with the understanding of artistic
laws or artistic principles. This thing is not to say that we invented it and
used it to stipulate others, but after a lot of summarization and analysis,
from experience, which kind of fluency is good, or which kind of feeling is
more likely to make people feel, this thing is for your reference. You can use
it or not.
Some people don't like the word routine, but there are more
routines in the art. Theories are all summed up. They all rely on us to
practice and then discover the conclusions drawn from the inductive analysis.
It is very remarkable to follow 90% of the routines and 10% of innovations in
art. If 90% are innovations, they can't listen.
Source: (Katja News)
ConversionConversion EmoticonEmoticon